What the Court Actually Refused to Decide
On 16 November, the Supreme Court issued an order list containing denials of two petitions for writ of certiorari challenging subject matter eligibility under 35 U.S.C. § 101, according to IPWatchdog. The denials continue what the publication describes as the Court’s trend of ignoring alarms raised about the Federal Circuit’s application of the two-step Alice Corp. v. CLS Bank International test — particularly the intra-circuit development of conflicting standards for computer-related inventions.
The first petition, Innovaport v. Target Corp., concerned patents claiming a means for helping customers locate items in a store. Although two of the asserted patents had overcome Section 101 objections at the USPTO, the Western District of Wisconsin found the claims invalid and the Federal Circuit affirmed, holding at Alice Step 1 that the claims were directed to the abstract idea of analysing, customising and displaying information. Innovaport argued that cases the Federal Circuit relied on for evading deference to USPTO eligibility determinations do not permit those determinations to be completely disregarded, and that the court ignored preemption arguments about claims it said were narrowly tailored.
The second, Oasis Tooling v. Siemens Industry Software, concerned patents for analysing semiconductor chip designs. The Federal Circuit conceded that “human minds are unable to” perform the patented steps, yet affirmed ineligibility this February. Oasis Tooling argued that an intra-circuit split has developed between McRO v. Bandai Namco Games America (2016) — asking whether the claimed process differs from the prior conventional human process — and cases such as PersonalWeb Technologies v. Google (2021), which found patents ineligible when the function is generally accomplishable by the human mind even where the specific claimed steps are not.
How This Differs From the Petition Denied in October
This is not the first refusal. As the source notes, the petition in US Patent No. 7,679,637 LLC v. Google was also denied by the Court this October, after flagging that the Federal Circuit blurred the line between its Step 1 and Step 2 analysis by failing to cite record evidence that claim elements were well-understood, routine or conventional. Innovaport raised the same concern.
The difference is the nature of the challenge. The earlier petition focused on how the Alice steps are applied. These two petitions asked the Court to resolve a structural conflict inside the Federal Circuit itself — one that exclusive appellate jurisdiction makes particularly difficult to correct from below. Oasis Tooling pointed to the fractured en banc rehearing denial in Athena Diagnostics v. Mayo Collaborative Services (2019) as proof that Supreme Court intervention is required.
No figures, claim statistics or eligibility rates appear in the source, so any claim that the denial will change grant rates would be speculation. What is documented is the direct contrast in approach:
| Case line | Question asked | Outcome in the source |
|---|---|---|
| McRO v. Bandai Namco Games America (2016) | Does the claimed process differ from the prior conventional human process? | Cited by Oasis Tooling as the line favouring eligibility |
| PersonalWeb Technologies v. Google (2021) and others | Is the function generally accomplishable by the human mind, even if the specific steps are not? | Cited as the line finding patents ineligible |
| Sanderling Management v. Snap (2023) | Deference to USPTO eligibility determinations | Relied on by the Federal Circuit, per Innovaport, to render the USPTO’s determination moot |
The table is my synthesis of the petitions’ arguments as reported; it is not a ranking of which line is correct.
Three Practical Uses for Lawyers and Founders
1. Drafting with preemption in mind, not just abstractness. Innovaport’s petition argued that preemption must be substantively evaluated at Alice Step 1 and that Enfish v. Microsoft Corp. (2016) does not require computer-related claims to improve computer functioning. A patent attorney drafting a software claim can treat that as a checklist item: identify the specific technical limitation — Innovaport pointed to its claimed “information storage device” providing product locations based on past purchases — and write the specification so that limitation is visibly tied to a concrete mechanism rather than a result. Realistic example: a retail personalisation startup should not claim “recommending products based on purchase history” but the specific data structure and retrieval mechanism that produces the recommendation.
2. Litigation strategy for patentees who survived examination. Innovaport’s core point was the tension between the presumption of validity under 35 U.S.C. § 282 and the Federal Circuit’s treatment of USPTO eligibility findings. For a patentee whose claims overcame Section 101 objections, that record is an asset. Realistic example: before filing suit, map every examiner objection and response, and brief the court on why the agency’s determination deserves weight — rather than assuming the district court will consider it.
3. Portfolio triage for in-house counsel at software and semiconductor firms. Oasis Tooling’s claims required partitioning data into header and cell portions, atomising chip design and hashing data into a numerical string. That level of technical specificity did not save the patent on appeal, which is a warning. Realistic example: a semiconductor company reviewing its portfolio should ask, for each computer-implemented claim, whether the claimed steps are described in terms a human examiner could not perform — and secure that evidence in the record early, because the Federal Circuit did not credit it here.
Who Is Affected, and How
The immediate effect is on patent applicants and litigants in computer-related fields — retail location systems, semiconductor design tools and, by extension, software generally. The denials mean no new Supreme Court guidance on the Alice test, and the intra-circuit split Oasis Tooling described remains unresolved at the appellate level.
Second, the USPTO’s role is affected. Innovaport raised a public policy question: whether patentees can rely on agency eligibility guidance if the Federal Circuit can render the agency’s determination moot. That question now goes unanswered, which affects how much weight applicants should place on examiner outcomes when assessing risk.
Third, defendants gain stability. Every denial leaves the existing Federal Circuit framework intact, which favours parties defending invalidity challenges and those advising clients on freedom to operate. For firms, the practical consequence is that eligibility risk must be priced into patent strategy rather than resolved by waiting for the Court.
What to Watch: Limits, Records and Evidence
The central caution is evidentiary. Innovaport argued that the Federal Circuit failed to cite record evidence supporting its Step 2 finding that claim elements were well-understood, routine or conventional. If that criticism holds, the lesson for practitioners is that the record — not the argument — will decide these cases. Build the evidence at prosecution and preserve it through litigation.
Confidentiality and privilege matter too. Technical documentation used to prove that a claimed step is beyond human capability, as in Oasis Tooling, often contains sensitive design information. Review what enters the public record before relying on it.
On intellectual property, the split itself is the risk. Until the Federal Circuit or the Court resolves McRO versus PersonalWeb, two patents with similar specificity could receive different treatment depending on panel composition. Any internal eligibility policy should reflect that uncertainty rather than assume a single test.
Finally, professional limits. These are denials, not decisions on the merits. Nothing in the order list endorses the Federal Circuit’s analysis or rejects it. Reading the denials as approval of either line of cases would misstate what happened. For research discipline in an AI-assisted workflow, the same rule applies: verify before you rely — a point developed in our guide to verifying legal research before court.
How to Act on This Now
The source gives no timetable for further petitions and no indication that the Court will revisit the question. Practitioners should therefore treat the current framework as durable for planning purposes.
Three steps follow from the reporting. First, re-read the two petitions as advocacy documents: they set out precisely where the Federal Circuit’s reasoning is said to fail, and those arguments are reusable in district court and at the USPTO. Second, audit pending applications and issued claims against both lines of authority, and document technical limitations with evidence rather than assertion. Third, brief clients that eligibility outcomes depend heavily on how claims are framed and how the record is built — not on the availability of Supreme Court review.
For teams building AI-assisted patent workflows, the same discipline applies to drafting support and prior-art analysis: outputs must be checked against the specification and the prosecution history. Our overview of AI for lawyers sets out how to keep that verification step in place.
Sources
Frequently asked questions
What did the Supreme Court actually decide in these two cases?
It decided nothing on the merits. According to IPWatchdog, the Court issued an order list on 16 November denying petitions for writ of certiorari in Innovaport v. Target Corp. and Oasis Tooling v. Siemens Industry Software. The Federal Circuit decisions below therefore stand, and no new guidance on Section 101 or the Alice test was issued.
Why does the intra-circuit split matter for computer-related inventions?
Oasis Tooling argued that one line of Federal Circuit cases, following McRO v. Bandai Namco Games America, asks whether the claimed process differs from the prior conventional human process, while another, including PersonalWeb Technologies v. Google, finds claims ineligible when the function is generally accomplishable by the human mind. Because the Federal Circuit has exclusive jurisdiction over patent appeals, that conflict cannot be resolved by another circuit.
Does the denial mean USPTO eligibility determinations carry no weight?
Not exactly. Innovaport argued that the Federal Circuit relied on cases that render the USPTO’s eligibility determination moot, and that this raises public policy issues about whether patentees can rely on agency guidance. The Court declined to address the question, so the practical weight of an examiner’s eligibility finding remains unsettled rather than eliminated.
Want to apply this to your own work or your team? Tell me where you stand, and I will reply personally.
Get in touch
